GUY 2 seems like the better choice in my opinion ;3

Go with the guy that tries the hardest

I think you should go with the second guy cause he only tries to be manly in front of his friends but if you make some kind of advance I think he'll melt and besides he likes anime too and you've known him longer, I reckon go with him...

@KyraChan:

Ah, yes, that is where I heard it from!

@Kazamas-Keyblade:

Not gunna lie. I submitted the exact same situation to Ask Moka, if that's what you're thinking about.

(I think I've heard this somewhere on here before...Or maybe something similar by pure coincidence.)

I say G1.
Seems that you and G2 have a more buddy-buddy relationship that should not be spoiled by the pressure and standards of being in a relationship.