I'd suggest Kanon, Clannad and AnoHana, all of these are sad and the last one is slice of life which you don't want x3. Though it is great. 
Hmm...Shugo Chara, Dengeki Daisy (a manga, no anime til now), I also recommend Fairy Tail. Are you not into shounen? I'd recommend Black Cat, Bleach and one piece  (*ﾉωﾉ) .

Rozen maiden is great （＾ ＾）. 

@Vanilla Cupcake :

Your welcome. （＾_＾）
It is adorable. The story is awesome too! (*≧▽≦)

@Viollet:

Rozen Maiden looks adorable! I'll try it out~ Thanks for the help!

What about Rozen Maiden and Fairy Tail? ヽ(^o^ヽ)

@Hifsa:

Thanks!

@luicifers wife:

Ok cool! I'll check 'em out~! Thanks

you might like saiyuki
than thare is yu yu hakusho or the wallflower out of the 3 listed the wallfower is the most girly

@Vanilla Cupcake :

I can't exactly explain, you can search online

@Snowzi:

Thanks for the list!

@Hifsa:

I didn't exactly watch Kimi ni Todoke. Too draggy. K-On is too :-/
Tamako market sounds OK, what's it about??

By pure chance I stumbled across this today: http://www.top10slist.com/top-10-animes/

Adding to the list - Fruits Basket, Baka & Test, Soul Eater, Durarara, Eden of the East, Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles, Fairy Tail, One Piece... seriously I could go on for years...

You didn't mention kimi ni todke...hyou can watch that if you haven't or watch k-on and tamako market, if you want to watch short series :)